Monday, February 16, 2015

Diets Fail! Or, do they?! Tools for Measuring Success

Them: What kind of diet are you on?
Me: Real Food.

More on how I define Real Food (see 3b).

I understand the need to identify what protocol works best for your situation. Those that are in-tune with their body will be better at determining which diet may be necessary. For some, it's for weight loss, but for many, it's to feel good. There's something about adding life to our years. My hope is that through my resources - my blog, presentations, and classes, you will be encouraged to advocate for your wellness, read your labels, partner with your practitioner, and always do your own research.

Why do diets fail?

Simply put, many are unable to stick to it. Why is that? Maybe, the particular diet chosen didn't align with the individual's needs - for today (short term) and tomorrow (in the long run).  Let's explore some reasons why diets many times do not work:

1) Don't Feel Good
2) Hunger
3) Cravings
4) Social Pressure
5) Lack Results
6) Too Rigid
7) Budget or Lifestyle
8) Bored

Some choose a protocol (aka diet) that is temporary. It is what helps them identify the triggers that is causing their sickness and discomfort. Many times, they stay the course longer than they had originally planned. Other times, they may incorporate one new food item during a period of time like an Elimination Diet (How tos by: Mind Body Green and Precision Nutrition) to determine which foods align or damage. This is part of the wellness journey.

Lifestyle vs. Diet

Choose a lifestyle regardless if this includes a diet or protocol of your choosing. I like to call it a health regimen. It places the priority on health which to me means long term. I guess it's all a matter of opinion but use words that empower your journey and be confident in your research and choices. Always be open to changes because they 'gon come! 

Dieting is often referred to as weight cycling (yoyo dieting) in which you are choosing different programs to achieve certain results (primarily weight loss) over long-term wellness changes.

What does weight cycling comprise of?

1. You start to lose weight.
2. You quit your diet because you've a) met your goal or b) can't keep it up.
3. You return to your old eating habits.
4. You gain the weight previously lost right back.
5. Frustrated with your weight, you go on a diet.

Weight Cycling May Cause:

- Decrease in muscle mass if not exercising. 
(More muscle = more calories burned; less muscle = less calories burned)
- Mental distress (fear of failure (again))
- Life dissatisfaction
- Self doubt
- Anxiety

Healthy and Sustainable Weight Loss

Losing 1-2 pounds a week is sustainable. Sure, it doesn't sound like a lot and if you're on the heavier side, you're already calculating how long that's going to take. But, give yourself some grace. It may take time, but during this process, you'll be fine tuning new habits and you'll look back one day and see how far you've really come!

Take baby steps. You already know how much I tout this as a general rule in your wellness journey. I'm a baby stepper. It works! Sure, you can go cold turkey and go all in so if your personality supports this action then give it a try and it's okay if you have to pull back a bit and go slower during different seasons in the journey.

Support system. This is an essential part of the protocol for most. We just do better when we have a buddy or a team of supporters. Look for your tribe. Can't find one? Create one. 

I'm also learning more about support systems in place with insurance providers like this integrative health care policy holder of New York and New Jersey, Hi Oscar, and gyms who tout YOLO (you only live once) like in the city of Lancaster, CA where they're offering cash rewards for meeting daily personal activity goals. 

I am sure there are more programs! If you know of any in your area, comment with your city, state, and / or zip code and the program in place.

Include behavioral changes in your journey. This is having the right attitude for your situation.  It isn't solely about dietary changes or movement. Food is the foundation but movement is important and so is having a healthy upbeat attitude. Do what you can with what you have. There is always a way!

Add in one simple change. This was also covered in my New Year Solutions post. I also think that this along with the baby steps compliment each other. You get to choose what that one simple change is and how long it takes you to make it part of your lifestyle.

This one simple change could include the incorporation of a fitness tool or app. How does one figure out which app or tool is best? The best way may be to ask friends that are into fitness. Another way is to search fitness apps on your smart phone and look at the reviews. 

Let's Talk Fitness Apps and Tools

My Fitness Pal is an app on your smart phone (iPhone or Android) and can be used on a computer.

My Fitness Pal helps you see what you burn with exercise, keeps count of your calories, and has a heart rate monitor, it also puts your foods consumed in a pie chart so you can identify food groups easily, however, I see it is a lot of data entry but they have over 2M foods listed so that's convenient. This app may be suitable for someone who already understands the importance on the quality and source of foods and they are eating somewhat balanced hitting all the food groups (to their preference). Quality and source starts from a firm understanding of ingredients. The other benefit to using My Fitness Pal is that it talks to other apps and two of them are below - FitBit and Runtastic. 

The iPhone has a Nike +iPod chip that goes on your shoe. One runner mentioned that this app doesn't talk to My Fitness Pal but she likes that it's located on her shoe - out of the way and spot on tracking of steps. There is also an app with an iPhone. She keeps her phone in her back pocket, in a hoodie, or in the strap of her sports bra, so that it can track her movement. "You connect your iPod to your computer to upload the data from each outing."

The FitBit Flex keeps track of calories burned and calories consumed. The FitBit can sync to other apps on the smart phone where it uploads the information. One runner said: "I like the FitBit because I don't have to manually input my calories burned. I've had my FitBit Flex for almost 2 months and I really like it." The FitBit Flex also tracks sleep patterns. FitBit One was recommended by a gal who used it to lose weight the year before so that she could have a higher change of conception. She was able to have a baby! The One is different than the Flex as it clips to clothes; the Flex is an armband. 

Another runner: "I learned about the FitBit Flex from my doctor, then I went on to the website to learn a little more. For me personally, it has helped me to better manage my calories because I can see what I'm burning on a normal day and what I'm consuming after I enter in what I ate. Since I have started using the FitBit (right before Thanksgiving) I have lost 12 lbs. I have the My Fitness Pal but I am really bad about entering in my calories burned from exercising. I like that the FitBit does that for me automatically so I have the "instant gratification" of knowing that I am still within my allowable calories for the day."

Runtastic is an app for the smart phone and also has a tracker. It is about $20 cheaper than the FitBit. From what the running groups were sharing, the consensus leaned towards FitBit but it's best for you to do your own research and how much you're willing to spend. 

Oscar Insurance (Hi Oscar) is available for health insurance in New Jersey and in New York; they're a different kind of insurance provider. They want to offer preventative health resources in addition to their standard claims, providers, and benefits coverage. Oscar Insurance just started offering the MisFit Flash to their members for which they can earn a dollar every day for meeting daily personal fitness goals. I really like that they are offering cash rewards for their members. 

So that I don't reinvent the wheel, ACE recently (Jan 2015) wrote a post on the top five fitness trackers and offered up their bottom line (visit their link to see how the five models stacked up against each other). But I will gladly share this: They said that 30-40% of people are more active when they use trackers. I can definitely see that! When I'm food logging, I am much more conscientious of my food choices and when I'm wearing my pedometer, I definitely park even further from the front door and actively look for ways to increase my steps! 

My Thoughts

I personally measure my wellness success on how I feel and how many fruits and vegetables I consumed with clean protein sources. You may like to read more about adding plants for heart health post. Frisky Lemon says that she measures her weight by how many pounds she can squat and how many vegetables she eats. She also says that her weight does not equal her health. 

I currently use a pedometer. It's basic and I'm okay with that for now. I take a weekly average of steps then I try to increase that number by a couple hundred each day the following weeks. Taking averages helps us identify a starting place. I plan to purchase a different tool in the coming weeks and right now, I'm leaning towards a FitBit One but I plan to do more research before I make a final decision. 

Calorie counting, in my opinion, should never be used as the primary marker in one's wellness journey. There should be a focus on quality and source. If your goal is 2,000 calories and you ate 2,000 calories and it was mostly protein and packaged foods well, is that balanced, was it nutrient dense, was it chock full of preservatives and MSG? You can learn all of this in the ingredients list. Make most of your choices real food paying attention to quality and source. This philosophy can be taught with a nutrition consult with me.

Lifestyle changes are sustainable! Choose which one aligns with your needs today and what may compliment where you see yourself next month or next year. If you want to incorporate supplements, do your research on the ingredients and ask if they offer ongoing education with and outside of the product or program you choose. 

Eat real food and incorporate movement every day!

My last tip: Run far away from any program that doesn't offer any education on quality and source of food ingredients or any program that solely teaches calorie counting. You are likely to burn out. Being in-tune with our body is best. Listen to and honor it and give it nourishing foods!

Choose, eat, and live well! =)

I do receive a small commission from my affiliates if you purchase anything through their sites using one of the links above (read my full advertising disclosure here). 

Thank you very much for your generosity in helping to offset the costs of website upkeep, so that I can keep sharing wellness resources with my community and beyond.

Download my free eGuide when you subscribe to my newsletter and / or subscribe to my blog here to never miss a post.

Print This Post


  1. This is a really good "f.ood" for thought read! Thank you for all your helpful tips

  2. Awesome points you are making here Jessica. I like the point about making baby steps. When changing your lifestyle around, changing too many things at once is too overwhelming and can stop you from continuing. It is better to be slow but steady. I also use FitBit, mine is the Charge HR, and I absolutely love it.

    1. Thanks for your personal feedback on which fitness tracker you use. Baby steps can create sustainable, good habits. Be well! =)

  3. This is a great summary of roadblocks which may be hindering anyone from getting healthy and losing weight (if necessary). I think weight loss should be a side-effect of getting healthy, not the other way around.

    I am not fond of the term "fat" because the excess that's there isn't fat, it's usually toxins the body has stored because it didn't know what else to do with it.

    This is an excellent article for those who have been on dieting yo-yos for a period of time, and hope it provides motivation and inspiration for good health!

    1. Loving yourself enough to feed your body well and move it well. Yes, weight loss (or in some cases, [healthy] weight gain), is a byproduct of a fulfilling wellness journey. Thanks for stopping by!

  4. I love Fitness Pal. You can't lie to it! Please the site offers great exercises too.

    1. That's great to know, Anna, thank you for sharing that helpful feedback on the app's optional resources.

  5. Great tips! I love the idea of lifestyle changes versus diets. I liked this point, "she measures her weight by how many pounds she can squat and how many vegetables she eats. She also says that her weight does not equal her health."

  6. I love your bit about fitness. It really changes our mindset and helps the eating changes stick, a whole new lifestyle. Thanks for sharing your insights.

  7. A simple pedometer is good enough. We bought FitBit for my hubby for his birthday and he used it for about 3 weeks. Once he noticed his pattern, he stopped using it. What a waste of money. All the gadgets and apps in the world can not make you move or get healthy. YOU have to want it and be disciplined enough to make 'any' regimen to be part of your LIFESTYLE. Great post Jessica!

    1. Thanks a lot for leaving some personal feedback. Yes, I agree, the pedometers are simple and easy to use. I wear mine daily. I still haven't decided on a different fitness tracker. Thanks for echoing my sentiments about a lifestyle choice - fitness and eating well. =)

  8. Hi Jessica,
    This subject always challenges and intrigues me so thank you for enlightening us on the topic of diets at the Healthy, Happy, Green and Natural Party Blog Hop. I'm pinning and sharing!